The Mortician and the Masses: Aldous Huxley’s “The Perversion of Values” (1926) Reconsidered

Elgin ad, Vanity Fair, Oct. 1926

“Something is happening on the western shore of the Atlantic.”  Aldous Huxley said as much.  To be sure, given the long stretch of this vaguely defined region, something is bound to happen there at any time.  Huxley was in fact referring to the United States of America when he made that statement in his article “The Perversion of Values,” which was published in the October 1926 issue of Vanity Fair.

The English author and philosopher was a frequent contributor to the periodical in those days, and “The Perversion of Values,” like the previously discussed article “The Present Fad of Self Confession,” of the same year, was presented as part of a series of provocative commentaries on the provoking currents of the age.  What was “happening” in the United States, Huxley opined this time around, was “something” that “threaten[ed] to separate it still further from the older civilizations, unless (which God forbid) the older civilizations should themselves fall victims to the same distorting process.”

You said something there, I said to myself, as I caught up with Huxley’s argument a century later.  Having said as much, I feel compelled as well to follow this up by that time-honored cry of exasperation: “you don’t know the half of it.”  Then again how could Huxley have known just how much further values could be perverted in an age in which a US President acts like—and as—a perverter-in-chief?

Alive to the dangers of presentism, I acknowledge that the phrase “victims to the same distorting process” is not a response to the political landscape of our day but to the radical and rapid transformation of Western societies in the Roaring Twenties.  Huxley was not, as I am, concerned with the threat to democracies the world over but with the dangers posed by democratic values and the to him dubious revaluation of established standards.  And it was not some pamphleteering demagogue, political rally or protest staged by wary and worked-up citizens that triggered, or at any rate occasioned, Huxley’s public performance of panic.  It was, he claims, a page in the Chicago telephone directory.  How anxious can you get?

Willys-Knight ad featuring crime novelist Mary Roberts Rinehart (Vanity Fair, Oct. 1926)

Now, I am posting this entry—the 877th—on Halloween; but however susceptible that might make me, I find it difficult to imagine being quite so startled by an advertisement, even if the one placing it is a mortician.  Huxley’s “eye was fatally caught,” and the arresting message was all the more menacing not for the service it promoted but for what it represented.  “The page on which I now gazed was something more,” Huxley declared, “than a mere page of advertising in a telephone book.  It was a page out of contemporary American history.”  In short, it struck him as a “symptom and a revealing symbol.”

We need not dwell on Huxley’s reference to the no doubt fictitious funeral director Mr. Kalbsfleisch (whose name is German for veal) and his wife, a licensed embalmer.  Intriguing but in itself irrelevant, it is little more than a MacGuffin with which to set his argument in motion and pronounce that what was “happening in America” was a “revaluation of values” and a “radical alteration (for the worse) of established standards.”  The Kalbsfleisch enterprise, real or imagined, served to demonstrate “how far the process has already gone.  How much further it may go we cannot guess.”

How much further this “Perversion of Values” was suspected to have gone was expressed nearly a decade later in Cole Porter’s tune of blissful resignation, “Anything Goes” (1934):

The world has gone mad today And good’s bad today, And black’s white today, And day’s night today …

By now, the ditty has turned into a dirge.  Not “Anything Goes” but “What the hell happened?” No guesswork required.  Look no further than the US midterm election campaign trail, strewn as it was with stale leftovers of yesterday’s alternative facts, with crude remarks and shameless slurs discharged in seemingly endless tirades by an irritable holder-on to the highest political office he brought so lamentably low.  Too self-absorbed to notice, he stoops ever lower to conquer what he has lost at last and, as is gradually becoming apparent even to some of his supporters and enablers, should never have had in the first place.

Look no further than down on a man of business, much of which shambolic, who does not know or care to learn the meaning of service, who belittles and demeans, who lavishes praise on those who serve themselves by raiding coffers, or countries, and who razes to the ground whatever does not serve him as a platform, a palace or a private playground, be it for games of golf or gratification of the sort you file under Jeffrey Epstein.

Lincoln ad, Vanity Fair, Oct. 1926

While Huxley cannot tell us how we got here, his views on the processes by which values decline and standards erode are nonetheless instructive.  There are, he writes,

only two ways in which the existing standards of value may be altered.  In the first case, the very existence of values may be denied.  In the second, values are admitted, but the mode in which they are assigned is changed: things which in the past had been regarded as possessing great value are disparaged, or, more often, things which were previously considered of small value come to be regarded as precious.

To Huxley, the latter process applies to the case of the resourceful man of business who elevates his status by calling himself “mortician” and by boasting about his services as if they were equal to the contributions made to society by artists or scholars. “He is an undertaker,” Huxley scoffs.

The trade he practises has never enjoyed great esteem; for, although it is a necessary trade, it cannot be said to call for high intellectual or moral qualities in its practitioners.  Mr. Kalbsfleisch and his fellows have realized and resented this failure on the part of humanity to esteem them.  Being good [98] democrats, they want to insist on their equality admittedly best people.  They begin by altering the name of their trade.  The word “undertaker” has base associations.  They therefore coin a new locution style themselves “morticians.”  “Mortician” is a word that rhymes with such highly reputable words as physician, mathematician, academician, politician—not to mention Titian.  What’s in a name? Much.  From having been undertakers and mere tradesmen, the morticians have become artists and members of an almost learned profession.

Although I do not subscribe to Huxley’s views on the dangers of democratic levelling, I share his concerns about the ways in which standards of academic excellence and scientific rigor are being devalued. ‘Stupidity, suggestibility and business are held up as supremely precious,” Huxley exclaims, whereas “[i]ntelligence and disinterested activity—once admired—are in process of becoming evil things which ought to be destroyed.”

Advertisements for “Schools that are Different,” Vanity Fair, Oct. 1926

At present, the widespread distrust of intellectuals and the vilification of researchers are achieved by populist politicians who seek to ingratiate themselves with the masses, the otherwise untouchables they have no interest in uplifting through education but value only in terms of their ability to elevate self-serving business tycoons to the status of icons and idols worthy of worship, oligarchs who, propelled into the stratosphere, are beyond scrutiny and no longer approachable even through emulation.

Values do not simply vanish.  They are being traded for ersatz.  According to Huxley, the exchange occurs in the marketplace of democracy: “This falsification of the standard of values is a product, in our modern world, of democracy and has gone furthest in America.”

It is much more dangerous than the mere denial of values, because it is much more popular.  To most men and women the denial of values is horrible; but the falsification of them so as to square with democratic prejudices is pleasant and flattering.

Clearly, Huxley is less concerned about perverted values than he is about the conditions to which he attributes them.  A thinker with demonstrably undemocratic “prejudices,” he is devaluing a system that was predicated on the notion that, since anyone can potentially be of value to it, everyone should be considered equal in it, whether or not that potential is realized. Huxley rejects equality as the “basic democratic hypothesis in its extreme and most popular form.”

What seems to trouble Huxley, existentially, is the erasure of boundaries, a collapse of hierarchies that may lead anyone to insist “I am just as good as you are.”  Turning “valuable” into “good,” Huxley reframes the question of “equality”—a construct that his Proper Studies (1927) would consider at greater length—in moral rather than legal terms.  To him, the assumption that everyone is equally good, rather than equal by virtue of being good for something and therefore good for the greater good, is “so manifestly untrue” that a

most elaborate system of humbug has had to be invented in order to render it credible to any normally sane human being.  Nowhere has this system of humbug been brought to such perfection as in America.

What Huxley refers to as a “system of humbug” is a democratic system of government that, however flawed in its ambition, has enabled millions of citizens to lift themselves up or prevented them from being kept down for the benefit of the few.

The irony that Huxley’s remarks appear in a periodical catering to the few and touting the services of the many carmakers, hosiers and hatters those few require to stand out even among the few has not escaped me.  The advertisements shown here are from the same issue of Vanity Fair that carried Huxley’s article.  One of them, a grouping of ads for private schools, brings home to me what is most problematic about Huxley’s argument: while the “few” of whom he speaks are not the affluent but the bold, intelligent and the ostensibly gifted, the question arises: Who bestows such gifts? Providence? Are the gifted born to be the chosen “few” or does the education they can afford enable them to stand out, rise above the rest, and distinguish themselves?

In Huxley’s argument, “few” is equated with “precious,” a rarified air of quality that betokens high standards and great value. Democracy, so Huxley, is not rewarding the exceptional few.  Instead, it is encouraging the many to bring down and supersede the few. These days, however, the encouragement to reject standards and values comes from the few who are most hostile toward democracy.

In Huxley’s argument, “few” is equated with “precious,” a rarified air of quality that betokens high standards and great value. Democracy, so Huxley, is not rewarding the exceptional few.  Instead, it is encouraging the many to bring down and supersede the few. These days, however, the encouragement to reject standards and values comes from the few who are most hostile toward democracy.  Huxley was hoping for meritocracy.  What we get once democratic values are perverted is oligarchy.

Why point the finger at the aspirational mortician? What harm does he pose to the living? The danger lies in the threat to freedom of expression and the right to vote.  The undertaker of democracy is the current occupier of the White House he has already begun to tear down, not just symbolically but systematically so that he and his embalmed cronies may rid themselves of the values and standards that, far from being inviolate, are democratically achieved.


Discover more from Harry Heuser

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Leave a Reply