The Darwin bicentenary is drawing to a close. Throughout the year, exhibitions were staged all over Britain to commemorate the achievements of the scientist and the controversy his theories wrought; numerous plays and documentaries were presented on stage, screen and radio, including a new production of Inherit the Wind (1955), currently on at the Old Vic. I was hoping to catch up with it when next I am in London; but, just like last month, I my hopes went the way of all dodos as only those survive the box office onslaught who see it fit to book early.
Not that setting foot on the stage of the Darwin debate requires any great effort or investment once you are in the great metropolis. During my last visit to the kingdomโs capital, I found myselfโthat is to say, I was caught unawares as I walked through the halls of the Royal Academy of Artsโin the very spot where, back in 1858, the papers that evolved into The Origin of Species were first presented.
This week, BBC Radio 4 is transporting us back to a rather less dignified scene down in Dayton, Tennessee, where, in the summer of 1925, the theory of evolution was being put on trial, with Clarence Darrow taking the floor for the defense. Peter Goodchild, a writer-producer who served as researcher for and became editor of the British television series on which the American broadcast institution Nova was modeled, adapted court transcripts to recreate the media event billed, somewhat prematurely, as the “trial of the century.”
Like the LA Theatre Works production before it, this new Radio Wales/Cymru presentation boasts a pedigree cast including tyro octogenarians Jerry Hardin as Judge John Raulston and Ed Asner as William Jennings Bryan, John de Lancie as Clarence Darrow, Stacy Keach as Dudley Field Malone, and Neil Patrick Harris as young biology teacher John Scopes, the knowing if rather naive lawbreaker at the nominal center of the proceedings who gets to tell us about it all.
โI was enjoying myself,โ the defendant nostalgically recalls his life and times, anno 1925, as he ushers us into the courtroom, for the ensuing drama in which he was little more than a supporting player. โIt was the year of the Charleston,โ of Louis Armstrongโs first recordings, โthe year The Great Gatsby was written.โ Not that marching backwards to the so-called โMonkey trialโ isโor should ever becomeโthe stuff of wistful reminiscences. โBut, in the same year, Hitler wrote Mein Kampf, Scopes adds, โand in Tennessee, they passed the Butler Act.โ
Darrow called the ban on evolution as a high school subjectโand any subsequent criminalization of intellectual discourse and expressed beliefsโthe โsetting of man against man and creed against creedโ that, if unchallenged, would go on โuntil with flying banners and beating drums, we are marching backwards to the 16th century.”
He was not, of course, referring to the Renaissance; rather, he was dreading a rebirth of the age of witch-hunts, superstitions and religious persecution. โWe have the purpose of preventing bigots and ignoramuses from controlling the education of the United States, and you know it, and that is all,โ Darrow declared.
It is a line you wonโt hear in the play; yet, however condensed it might be, the radio dramatization is as close as we get nowadays to the experience of listening to the trial back in 1925, when it was remote broadcast over WGN, Chicago, at the considerable cost of $1000 per day for wire charges. According to Slate and Cookโs It Sounds Impossible, the courtroom was โrearranged to accommodate the microphones,โ which only heightened the theatricality of the event.
I have never thought of radio drama as ersatz; in this case, certainly, getting an earful of the Darrow-Bryan exchange does not sound like a booby prize for having missed out on the staging and fictionalization of the trial as Inherit the Wind.
Related post
โInherit the . . . Air: Dialing for Darwin on His 200th Birthdayโ















Nearly two centuries ago, young Rebecca Sharp marked her entrance into the world by hurling a book out of a coach window. That book, reluctantly gifted to her by the proprietress of Miss Pinkertonโs academy for young ladies, was Johnsonโs dictionary, a volume for which Ms. Sharp had little use, given that she was rarely at a loss for words. By the time her story became known, in 1847, words in print had become a rather less precious commodity, especially after the British stamp tax was abolished in 1835, which, in turn, made the emergence of the penny press possible. Publications were becoming more frequentโand decidedly more frivolous.